|
Last November, the Fed officially announced its plans for a second round of quantitative easing — better known as QE2. This was a step most experts confidently professed would destroy the dollar.
Despite the bear-mania surrounding the dollar at the time, I saw it differently, especially given the hindsight provided from the Fed’s first adventure with QE.
My conclusion: It was clear that a draconian outcome for the dollar wasn’t in the cards.
So three days after the Fed’s announcement, I showed you seven charts here in Money and Markets that made the case for the buck.
And I’ve been proven right …
In fact, the dollar is higher now against a benchmark basket of currencies than it was before QE2!
Today, as we’ve reached the half-way point of the Fed’s QE2 program, I’d like to revisit those seven charts from November 6, 2010 and look back on how my analysis has played out.
Chart #1:
Long-term dollar cycles
My analysis then: The chart below is the roughly seven-year cycles in the dollar, dating back to the failure of the Bretton Woods system 40 years ago. These cycles argue that a bull cycle in the dollar started in March 2008.
That would put the dollar just 2.6 years into its new bull cycle or a bit more than a third of the way through a typical long-term dollar cycle.
Without question, this recent cycle has been very volatile. But the buck continues to trade comfortably above its 2008 all-time lows and the lows of last year [2009], making higher lows along the way — a bullish pattern.
Here’s what happened: The dollar bottomed a day after the Fed’s formal announcement on QE2 and rose nearly 8 percent in the following weeks. It is still more than 1 percent stronger than it was last November and remains in a multi-year bull cycle.
Chart #2:
10-year dollar chart
My analysis then: The chart below shows the roughly seven-year downtrend in the dollar and the subsequent ascending channel that started in 2008. You can see that the dollar is now testing the bottom line of this bull channel, an attractive area to buy the greenback.
A bounce from these levels would project a move toward the top line of the channel or about 23 percent higher.
Here’s what happened: The dollar continues to hold the bottom line of this ascending channel (in red), which makes it a very attractive, low risk area to BUY dollars.
Chart #3:
10-year euro chart
My analysis then: This chart for the euro is essentially the inverse of the dollar. And here too, you can see a long multi-year trend, higher in the case of the euro, followed by a descending channel.
The euro also is bumping into a technical boundary, one that represents a downward trending channel. A fall from this level of resistance would open up a downside for the euro that would be right on target with most bearish estimates espoused when the euro zone was at the height of its crisis … parity versus the dollar.
Here’s what happened: The five-month rally in the euro topped out the day of the Fed’s November QE2 announcement. Over the next two months it fell nearly 10 percent against the dollar. And the world’s focus quickly turned back to the European sovereign debt crisis.
Since then, the euro has experienced another sharp bounce. But the multi-year downtrend is still well intact, projecting parity versus the dollar — perhaps as early as this year!
Chart #4:
Euro’s 22-week run
My analysis then: For more on the euro, consider this: The euro is in the midst of its strongest 22-week run on record, surpassing its prior record surge in 2003 — both areas are noted in the chart below.
What’s notable here is that in 2003, a 9 percent correction abruptly followed this strong climb. From current levels in the euro, a similar correction would mean a move down to 1.30 over the next few months.
Here’s what happened: The euro didn’t tumble 9 percent … it tumbled almost 10 percent! In just 17 short days in November, the euro fell from over 1.42 to just below 1.30. And it traded as low as 1.2872 against the dollar two months later.
Chart #5:
Pound still weak
My analysis then: Despite all of the fuss over the weak dollar, the British pound is still trading nearly 25 percent weaker against the dollar since the onset of the financial crisis three years ago.
And in the chart above, you can see that while the dollar and the euro are bumping into critical long-term technical areas, so is the pound.
Here’s what happened: The pound also topped out right around the date the Fed formally introduced QE2. And it fell nearly 6 percent in the months following. It still remains 23 percent off of its 2007 highs and is still entrenched in the long-term downtrend (defined by the declining white trendline).
Chart #6:
Yen near all-time highs
My analysis then: Now, for the Japanese yen, the other remaining major currency in the world …
This long-term chart in dollar/yen going back 40-years since the failure of the Bretton Woods system, shows its steady decline.
Even given its recent intervention the pair is nearing all-time lows (lows in the dollar, highs in the yen). From this chart, compared to the charts of the euro and the pound, you can see the lion’s share of dollar weakness over the past few years has come from the surging yen.
And now as this dollar/yen exchange rate nears all-time lows, the Bank of Japan is rolling out its most aggressive deflation-fighting act yet: With more QE, more fiscal policy and a cut in what’s left of its interest rate.
Plus, the Bank of Japan is officially in intervention mode — all things that make a case for a bounce in dollar/yen.
Here’s what happened: The dollar/yen relationship marked a 15-year bottom in the days surrounding the Fed’s QE2 announcement. Since then the dollar has staged a 5 percent run against the yen and continues to hold a stronger position.
Finally …
Chart #7:
Battle against the yuan
My analysis then: With the Fed’s QE2 policy officially on the table, the emerging market and Asian countries that have been waging a fight to keep their currencies from a runaway surge have already stepped up with more currency market intervention and talks of capital controls.
And they are doing so because the dollar is weakening. But more importantly they’re reacting because the Chinese yuan is getting weaker relative to their currencies in the process — a competitive disadvantage for their export trade.
Here’s what happened: Many of these countries have continued aggressive action to limit strength in their currencies. Meanwhile, the Chinese have continued to show resistance to any meaningful appreciation in the yuan — a dynamic I expect will continue, despite all of the expert predictions of a big one-off revaluation in the yuan to come.
To sum it up: The Fed’s decision to embark on another quantitative easing campaign dominated the world’s global markets for months in the third quarter of 2010. And most market chatter was squarely surrounding a doomsday scenario for the dollar. But it hasn’t played out that way.
My point in that November 6 column was this:
“A grossly weaker dollar is not an economically or politically acceptable proposition for the world. And trouble for the world economy represents trouble for the U.S. economy.
“So, despite all of the bold projections of a continued rout in the dollar, these seven charts suggest the exact opposite outcome could be around the corner.”
What’s the key takeaway today? All of this analysis still holds.
Regards,
Bryan
P.S. I see a lot of volatility ahead for all major currencies, including the dollar, euro, pound, yen and yuan. And that volatility can mean boatloads of profits for my World Currency Trader members. To see how you can join them, click here to view my latest presentation.
{ 8 comments }
Interesting article – but you’ve got to be kidding me! Showing charts from November without putting in the latest data and arguing that the analysis still holds?? I hate to break it to you Bry – the dollar index has made a lower high and a lower low since your “analysis” back in November. What a crock!
Kevin
Interesting analysis Bryan and one that I think makes a lot of sense. In spite of the fiscal problems facing the United States, the recent problems in the Middle East, especially Libya, have underscored a number of America’s strengths. Firstly, in spite of the rise of China (which has many Americans’ worriedly looking over their shoulders), America’s competitive advantage is that it is a Democracy with a strong tradition of rule of law. China may appear to be an economic powerhouse with incredible growth rates, but from a very low base it is difficult not to achieve high single digit growth.
Where the United States has a strong tradition of Democracy, China has a strong tradition of repression. The question should be asked which has the inherently more stable political system? Clearly it is the United States. Things seem stable now in China but what happens if China undergoes the sweeping democratization that the Middle East is going through. Clearly the worlds second biggest economy would experience chaos on an unprecedented scale.
However, if it is possible I wonder if you could put your mind to the following question for future columns. How would a VAT (value added tax) or Carbon Tax impact the American Economy? I have read that if America (despite overwhelming opposition from the Right) instituted a VAT it could solve its fiscal problems virtually overnight and solve its national debt problems over time. Also, what about a carbon tax? Of course, there would great opposition by the public to such a tax, but if such a tax was revenue neutral, in other words, it would lower some existing taxes to stimulate demand and production and consumption but increase taxes or tax carbon polluting industries to discourage the production of carbon dioxide. Would this not re balance the American Economy?
It seems to me that America’s problems, more than anything, are political. There are rational solutions out there that must be adopted to usher America into the 21st century. The good news is that the recent financial crisis has underscored America’s inherent political stability. And in spite of the overwhelming criticism levied at Ben Bernanke, he has saved capitalism from itself.
I don’t see American’s currency losing its reserve status any time soon. A basket of currencies might be necessary in the future, but this is not a bad thing. It would add stability to an uncertain world and would encourage America to adopt responsible economic policies. However, the coming demise of America has been greatly exaggerated. When people realize this, the American buck should rally to a more rational level.
Poppycock. I have been making money playing against the dollar with Australian and Brazilian bond. Gold and Silver have helped me as well. Long term, the dollar will continue it’s decline against these assets. “Supply and demand. Keep printing trillions of dollars and those selling commodities and buying our bonds will be demanding more dollars in exhange.
It’s ironic that in the middle of this article is an advertisement for how to get rich taking advantage of the currency wars, the race to the bottom in who can devalue their currency faster. The U.S. is winning that war as the currency pegs in emerging markets are causing real inflation problems and civil unrest. If the dollar rallies again, it will be because it is the least ugly of the crowd. It is equally likely that the Yuan will give up its peg and appreciate, putting downward pressure on the dollar.
The author’s arguments for a dollar rally are nearly all technical, while ignoring that the dollar broke through support on chart #2. He bases his assessment on past trends, without regard to the fact that we have not seen such a monumental intervention of “easing” in the past trend, yet we are to believe that this trend will continue, ignoring what the Fed is doing. The logic doesn’t follow. The dollar may indeed rally again, but this has not been confirmed by the technicals, yet.
Lastly, consider this recent market downturn; that the dollar has not been the safe-haven currency of the past. More people are fleeing to the Swiss Frank and precious metals than have in the past. Also consider that more than a dozen states have legislation pending that would make gold and silver legal currency. If this is not a sign that people are losing faith in the dollar, I don’t what is.
Thanks Bryan but there is one thing your article does not mention that I think is worth considering: what happens as we approach June 2011 and the prospect of QE 3???
Nice with a very long term analysis of USD and other pairs, especially from such a prominent analyst.
Q2 was specific, USD600 billion until June 2011, providing clarity and certainty. QE1 was a mess and billions were flying around in all directions. I have also noticed that USD seems to make some bottoms against some other currencies. A strong dollar rally can create enormous shortcovering, many shorts and carry traders out there. Markets tend to fool most people most of the time.
Interesting to read from analyst that state the facts especially when the majority is so bearish.
Thank you, Bryan. Sometimes, trader tends to looking into short term picture. A long term view really makes a good setup. All we need just a trigger to get into it. All the best.
Here’s a reason for a dollar rally: http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2011/03/07/dollar-doom-bets-hit-new-high