The Wrong and Right Way to Buy Gold

Nearly 21 months ago, one of the world’s leading analysts and proponents of gold shocked the investment community with the announcement that the yellow metal was headed south.

Most of his colleagues in the industry scoffed. But his loyal followers took action according to his explicit instructions:

They bought gold hedges for protection against the decline.

They liquidated all their mining shares.

And then they waited — sometimes patiently, sometimes anxiously — for his next major “buy” signal.

That gold analyst is Weiss Research’s Larry Edelson.

This week, I talked to Larry at length and reviewed his fascinating, but practical, writings. Here’s Part I of our three-part interview …

The Wrong and Right Way to Buy Gold

My Interview with Larry Edelson, Part I

Martin Weiss: Larry, today I want to focus on the major pitfalls to avoid. But before we jump into specific instructions, please lay out the full dimensions of the opportunity.

Larry Edelson: My analysis tells me the next leg of the gold bull market will not end for three full years. It will not peak until the yellow metal is at $5,000 per ounce or more. And it will spin off a long series of trading opportunities in virtually every investment that’s tied to gold and other precious metals — bullion, shares, ETFs, plus unique trades that most investors are unfamiliar with. I’m talking about the biggest gold opportunities since the Great Depression.

Martin: Talking about the Depression, my father told me how much money he and his colleagues made in the gold market back then.

Their Homestake shares surged from $65 to $540 per share. The company’s dividends doubled, redoubled and doubled again, reaching $56 per share in 1935. So the dividends alone were almost enough to pay back the entire purchase price of the stock.

Their shares in Dome Gold Mines did even better — surging from $6 to $61 per share and throwing off dividends that added up to two and a half times the purchase price of the shares.

Is this the kind of opportunity you see here?

Larry: Yes, but not if you jump in prematurely, like so many gold investors have continually done in the past 21 months or so.

Martin: I know … and as you well know, we’re counting on you to give us the signal. Don’t get me wrong. I recognize no one can ever pick the exact bottom. But if you can just get your readers back into the market reasonably close to a good buying zone, I think they will be forever grateful.

Larry: I’ll do my best. But first, a warning: All too often, investors jump into the precious metals markets thinking that, just because metals are tangible assets, they can’t possibly get ripped off.

But the sad truth is that they often are fleeced by hidden charges, conflicts of interest and, sometimes, outright frauds. This is especially the case in a long-term bull market when investors get complacent and rising prices help camouflage the fraud. When people are making good money, they don’t notice how badly they’re getting clipped.

For instance, in October 2009, Chinese-made counterfeit gold coins flooded online gold auctions and even flea markets — and that was just one example of more than 1 million fake coins that were sold in the U.S. alone.

Even legitimate “replica”-type gold- and silver-plated coins have become a hotbed for scams. In fact, Coin World reported that up to 99 percent of the “replica” items sold into the U.S. market do not contain the required “COPY” markings to make them legitimate replicas.

Martin: Let’s say I’m buying an Australian Nugget or a British Sovereign or a Canadian Maple Leaf, or even an American Eagle. How do I know whether it’s real or counterfeit?

Larry: You don’t. But one way to protect yourself is to buy bars from the refiner. If I bought a Johnson Matthey bar, and Matthey told me it was the original, straight from their refinery, that would be very reassuring. Ditto for Engelhard.

Fortunately, bullion coins are much harder to counterfeit than bars, because the designs are more intricate. Still, even with the coins, counterfeits can be a problem.

It’s almost impossible to make a counterfeit gold bullion coin that’s not obviously different in weight, diameter or width. So the key is to compare its weight and dimensions against a coin you know is real. Even if you’re not experienced with coins, you can tell the difference.

Martin: Suppose I want to buy a piece of jewelry made with gold coins?

Larry: Then buy the coins separately and give them to a jeweler you can trust to make the piece for you.

Martin: In one of your reports, you warned about counterfeit coins made with tungsten.

Larry: Yes, tungsten has the same density as gold. Until recently, a tungsten counterfeit would show up obviously as a counterfeit because the strikes were so poor. Now, with better technology, tungsten counterfeits are almost impossible to detect visually. But you can still use the “ringing test” to see if it’s real or not. Drop it on a hard desk. Then do the same for a coin that you know is real. You’ll hear a distinct difference in the sounds the two coins make.

Martin: I always see ads about so-called “mint state” and “limited edition” bullion coins that are supposedly worth much more than a common bullion coin. What do you think about that?

Larry: It’s pure hogwash. Bullion coins are not rare coins. Period. The governments and marketing firms that sell them don’t seem to care the least bit about the losses investors eventually incur.

If you want to buy bullion, stick with bullion coins you can buy with fair premiums over their melt value.

Stay away from the “limited edition,” “proof” or “mint state” claims, whether it be on proof Pandas, proof Krugerrands, proof U.S. Eagles, proof Sovereigns, proof Australian Nuggets or any other.

As for numismatic coins, they can be great. But it’s a market no one should invest in unless they are an expert, or have one at their disposal.

Martin: A big issue you write about is the premium an investor pays for bullion coins — in other words, how much more they cost than the metal itself. How should I calculate that premium?

Larry:  First, divide the price of the coin by the number of troy ounces of pure gold that it contains. That gives you the cost per ounce. For example, if a coin has 0.9999 troy ounces of pure gold and sells for $1,800. That’s $1,800 divided by 0.9999, or $1,800.18 per ounce.

But the spot price of gold at the time was $1,612. So you’d be  paying $188.18 per ounce extra for the gold in this coin. That’s your premium.

Convert that to a percentage, by dividing the $188.18 by $1,612, and you get 11.67 percent.

Martin: That seems darn high to me.

Larry: Darn right it is! But if you consistently use this simple formula, you can more easily sniff out the rotten offers and find the good ones.

Martin: What’s a reasonable premium for gold coins?

Larry: Premiums have gone up quite a bit already in recent years. But if a dealer tries to sell you coins at more than 5 percent over the actual value of the gold content — the average premium levels for a particular coin — I’d go elsewhere. You’d be paying too much.

Each bullion coin producer — the U.S. Mint, Canadian Mint, South African Mint, Chinese Mint, Australian Mint, etc. — builds in a mark-up for its coins, a premium over the pure bullion value or “melt value” of the coin. In each case, this premium varies.

Wholesalers also add a small premium to cover their cost of money and to make a profit on their inventory.

The retailer — the company you buy the coin from — also adds a mark-up.

So the premium over melt can vary widely as each mint, wholesaler and retailer add their pre-determined mark-ups.

Martin: So the lower, the better.

Larry: Not always. Yes, sometimes quality dealers deliberately underprice coins as a way of attracting new customers — like a credit card company that offers an extremely low introductory interest rate. And taking advantage of these opportunities might seem to be a great way to save money on bullion.

But in my experience, most dealers that advertise such gimmicks are out to ensnare you in their marketing net. As soon as you buy that one coin, ingot or bar from them, you’re bombarded with all sorts of deals that aren’t so good. And some that are outright fraudulent.

Moreover, if the firm is consistently selling bullion with premiums that are far below the competition, it raises my eyebrows. They can’t do that for an extended period and remain viable as a business.

Martin: You have helped a lot of people save a lot of money with their gold coin transactions. Can you give us some concrete examples of how that’s possible?

Larry: Sure. Again, let’s say that spot gold bullion is at $1,612 per ounce. And let’s say you bought 100 units of 1990 gold Pandas, the bullion coin issued by the Chinese. You’d pay about $240,000.

But that same $240,000 would buy 133 Austrian Philharmonics. So you would get an extra 33 coins, containing a bit less than 33 ounces of pure gold.

The extra gold you get is a dramatic addition to your portfolio — it’s like a free bonus you get for investing intelligently.

Alternatively, you could simply buy 100 ounces of gold in the form of Krugerrands for roughly $166,830 and pocket the difference — a healthy $73,170.

Martin: I get that. When it comes time to buy in significant amounts, what should I be looking at?

Larry: The Austrian 100 Corona and Hungarian 100 Korona are typically among the least expensive bullion coins (over spot) to buy.

They’re a beautiful reminder of the Austro-Hungarian empire. They’re both the same size, weight and alloy, but they have different designs.

I’ve also found that the South African Krugerrands can give a decent amount of gold for your dollar. It is synonymous in the public eye with 1 ounce of gold and, therefore, extremely liquid.

Martin: The importation of Krugerrands was banned in 1985, wasn’t it?

Larry: Yes. At the time, investors were bombarded with advertisements from dealers warning that severe losses were likely to befall Krugerrand owners.

These ads preyed on investors’ fears to try to get them to “swap” Krugerrands for Maple Leafs, Double Eagles or whatever the dealer happened to be pushing.

Martin: You warned our readers that this was pure poppycock. Were you right?

Larry: I was. And now, despite the fact the ban is over, we still hear of brokers who tell their clients that Krugerrands are dangerous. It’s complete nonsense.

The only reason a dealer would suggest switching your Krugerrands or recommending another product is pure profit. Krugerrand swaps can generate as much as an 8 percent net return for a dealer — between his buy-and-sell spread. And those who push other products are often receiving a higher net commission for those recommended products.

So if you own Krugerrands, sit on them. They still have international liquidity. They’ll always be worth the price of the gold that’s in them.

And for new gold holdings, the Krugerrands represent a cheap way to buy a single ounce of gold. But wait for my “buy” signal.

Martin: We definitely will. Plus, next week, please give us a series of other ways you recommend for buying precious metals.

Martin: Great! I think I can speak for our readers in thanking you very much for providing so much valuable information.

Larry: My pleasure.

 

---

 

EDITOR’S PICKS Stocks May Actually Get a Boost from Rising Rates by Mike Burnick Rising interest rates may be a blessing in disguise for stock investors, who have capped a rally of 15.4 percent in the benchmark S&P 500 this year on concern about higher bond yields. Japanese Ripples Head to U.S. Shores — Here’s How to Take Action by Bill Hall Japan is aiming to further weaken its currency and help its biggest companies sell more goods abroad. The Asian nation, by doing so, is exporting its problems, threatening a trade war that likely would turn ugly and claim financial victims across the world. Undervalued Global Bank Stocks: +61.83% One-Year Return by Gene Kirsch, Senior Banking Analyst The ten undervalued global bank stocks that we first selected as good investment values in May 2012 are up 61.83 percent after one year.  Eight of ten bank stocks continue to be fully valued at or above 100 percent of their initial price targets (see table below).

THIS WEEK’S TOP STORIES Bond Market Bombshell: Fed Official Gives ‘Sell’ Signal by Mike Larson If there’s any doubt that the generation-long bond-market rally has come to a close, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas President Richard Fisher just ended the discussion How Much Longer Will This Bull Market Run? by Douglas Davenport “To buy when others are despondently selling and sell when others are greedily buying requires the greatest fortitude and pays the greatest reward.” — Sir John Templeton The stock market is in trouble … but I’m not turning outright bearish by Larry Edelson The stock market is in trouble. I believe that the interim top that I have been waiting for is finally here. I can see it in the thinning volume in the Dow Industrials and the S&P 500 stocks. I can see it in the smaller and smaller number of stocks that have led the recent advance, compared to the number that are actually falling.

 

---