Dear #field8#,
Earlier this year, I wrote a Money and Markets piece titled “Social Unrest Setting the Stage for Sovereign Defaults.” We had already seen overthrows in Tunisia and Egypt, Libya was underway and other Middle East/North Africa flare ups were in the early stages.
In that February 26 column I laid out why a global movement could just be getting underway.
I said,
“… every step of the way through this global economic crisis the shocks have been thought to be contained. But they’ve proven time after time to be just the opposite: Contagious!”
That’s been the case with sovereign debt problems in Europe — once said to be contained and now known to be systemic. And it’s proving to be the case with public uprisings, too. It started in the Middle East, and now it continues to spread through Europe … as I said it would!
In Greece, protestors have turned violent, fighting to pressure parliament to reject more austerity demands from its euro-zone counterparts.
Spanish protestors have been in a month-long standoff, occupying a square in the capital of Madrid in what’s been called the Spanish Revolution. Last week, politicians in northeastern Spain were forced to enter parliament by helicopter or under police escort as protests grew against heavy cuts needed to slash its deficit.
The head of the biggest public sector union in the UK has announced it will be staging the biggest coordinated “action” in the history of the country, which could last months, to fight the job losses, tax hikes and benefit cuts.
As I’ve referenced many times here in Money and Markets, the most extensive study on historical global financial crises (by Harvard professor Kenneth Rogoff and University of Maryland professor Carmen Reinhart) shows us that fallout of widespread financial crises goes in four stages:
- Surge in fiscal deficits,
- Larger deficits turn into more debt,
- Bloated debts = downgrades, and
- Downgrades lead to sovereign debt defaults.
We’ve seen deficits grow in response to the financial crisis. We’ve seen debt levels explode. We’ve seen downgrades come one after another.
Anti-austerity protests across Europe could trigger the euro’s downfall. |
The next step: Sovereign debt defaults.
And despite global politicians’ best efforts, it starts in Greece.
It’s become increasingly clear that the trigger of a sovereign debt default in Greece won’t be from a “line in the sand” drawn by European politicians. To the contrary, they have proven that they will continue to do anything and everything to put off the day of impact.
I believe the end game in this crisis will be when the PEOPLE fully exert their power and say “no more.”
That’s when they say to their rich euro-zone neighbors …
“Keep Your Money, Keep Your Austerity
Demands and Keep Your Euro!”
When that happens, the Greeks, the Irish, and the Portuguese can free themselves from the rule of their euro-zone constituents, regain their sovereignty, re-instate their own currency and begin to rebuild.
Expect this public uprising to be the case, not just for Greece, but for people around the world who have continued to suffer while politicians bailout institutions and dig deeper and deeper holes.
While such a scenario may, at least, serve as pieces to put the world on a path of sustainable recovery, the near-term consequences would likely be:
A possible complete break-up of the euro, the second most widely held currency in the world,
Another global financial crisis where banks fail and credit freezes (again),
Return to recessions for many countries,
And another round of chaotic activity in financial markets.
Consider this …
Since early May the key markets that have been most closely linked to global risk appetite have definitively changed directions. The S&P 500, crude oil, silver, the euro and the Australian dollar all posted major long-term reversal signals in May. So did the U.S. dollar. The signal: An “outside range” … a pattern consistent with predicting major turning points.
Meanwhile, yields on U.S. Treasuries have plunged.
Despite all of the efforts by world central banks to add money in the system to stimulate recovery, little of it has actually reached the real economy.
With global economies slowing, risks rising and government intervention exhausted, all of the above market activities indicate that the smart-money is broadly preparing for another global storm.
In fact …
They’re Running for Cover!
The chart below shows the relationship between the velocity of money — the frequency with which money changes hands — and the performance of global stocks. You can see the plunge in the global velocity of money (in red) and the corresponding effect it tends to have on global stocks historically (in gray).
From this chart, the next three-month change in global stocks, as measured by the gray line, is likely down — in the neighborhood of 10 percent or more.
The last few times money velocity plunged at this rate were episodes of peak uncertainty surrounding the financial crisis of 2007-2008, and the European sovereign debt crisis of 2010.
I can’t guarantee what will happen from here. But if we use history as our guide, expect extreme volatility around the corner.
Regards,
Bryan
P.S. My World Currency Trader gives three ways you could profit during wild swings in currencies like we’re about to see. And I’ll even give you a money-back guarantee. You’ve got nothing to lose! Check out my latest presentation.
{ 8 comments }
Excellent article. Thanks!
Hi Bryan,
This is a wonderful piece of inteligent work on what has been happening in the realm of socioeconmics in the Midle East and Europe. I am wondering if a similar analysis is in the works as to when this socioeconomic tsunami crosses the Atlantic, and how it will manfest itself in our own country USA,
Respecfully,
Dan
If Greece overthrows the Euro and rejects austerity measures, how will that help Greece? They will still be in financial trouble and, at some point, will have to tighten their belt or default. Same for the US. Reality eventually wins out. When you run out of money, you run out of money.
Hi Bryan
An excellent piece and simply put. My investment friends and I have been accumulating cash for some time. Anyone who can’t see this coming just believes it won’t happen to them. When broad scale confidence starts to wane change will come with the toss of a coin. The pain in many asset classes will only be navigated with good preparation. Thank you for your insightful commentary. Howard Dimond.
I always look forward to your writings and yours only here.
Governments around the world are well aware of the potential civil unrests. When patience runs out, an eruption on the global scale will force profound changes to the status quo. Those governments know that too well but have no other options except to continue the current path simply because of who they are and whom they represent. You said it well: “the end game in this crisis will be when the PEOPLE fully exert their power and say “no more.—
The chairman of the Federal Reserve made this confession last week: “We don’t have a precise read on WHY this slower pace of growth is persisting,â€. Hmm! What does that tell us? How can you fix something if you don’t know why it’s broken? He neither knows it nor is he capable of fixing it.
I do believe that the financial crisis is a consequence of another deeper structural problem and the slower pace will get much slower. In the meantime more spending, money printing, borrowing, and zero interest rate will be the only remedy until people here say “no more”.
Cameron
i
You might well be right. Clearly all this was coming for some time. How come nobody noticed?
The same Cassandras who are now warning about impending collapse had nothing to say until recently. Further you have no idea what to do beyond selling us another publication.
It might be too late . Here are some suggestions. Close down our current wars. We have no idea about the cultures of the countries in which we currently fight. We are in no position to “build democracy”. Practice real energy conservation. Change the economy back from “throw away’ to “maintain and repair”. Develop clean energy sources. It’s all quite possible if there is a will.
During times of high taxation when we built he freeways and invested hugely in research and education and infrastructure the benefits to the country were incalculable. Those expenditures were needed to keep the country going. Now, we can’t afford to maintain what was built up. Not enough revenue. High taxes especially benefit the rich by the increase in the value of their assets. Conversely failure to raise the revenue to maintain he country will seriously jeopardize the assets of the rich.
Here is something to worry about. As it becomes harder to borrow money interest rates on US government instruments will increase. The wealthy will buy the bonds. To add insult to injury the rest of us will pay them their interest and retire the bonds out of our taxes.
Our leadership doesn’t have the understanding or the guts to do anything about this. I blame our wonderful culture with its priorities of athletics, religion and sex. This has promoted an atmosphere in which all beliefs are faith based and never mind the evidence. We have faith based climate, biology and even the age of the earth.
Congratulations.
Great presentation, but your chart needs to be bigger and more readable! Thanks, Tucker
The number of EU member states that will default is now out of control of the monetary union. This situation was predicted in that a one-value currency would not fit different countries valuations and costs of produced goods. Now we have a massively overvalued Euro and irrevocable fixed exchange rate set by the ESCB. Its true value is around 58 cents, as a system, its-fraud, Pawn broking and Betting on member countries Central Bank Depositors Assets.
And time to stop delaying the fallout, it is impossible to bailout and will only make the position considerably worse. Devalue before a fire sale of bank stock creates a much larger run on the Banks by the public. See extracts below;
Article 18 European System of Central Banks.
18.1. In order to achieve the objectives of the ESCB and to carry out its tasks, the ECB and the
National central banks may: operate in the financial markets by buying and selling outright (spot and forward) or under repurchase agreement and by lending or borrowing claims and marketable instruments, whether in euro or other currencies, as well as precious metals; conduct credit operations with credit institutions and other market participants, with lending being based on adequate collateral. In order to conduct their operations, the ECB and the national central banks may open accounts for credit institutions, public entities and other market participants and accept assets, including book entry securities, as collateral.
Article 30
30.1. Without prejudice to Article 28, the ECB shall be provided by the national central banks
with foreign reserve assets, other than Member States’ currencies, euro, IMF reserve positions and SDRs, up to an amount equivalent to euro 50 000 million. The Governing Council shall decide upon the proportion to be called up by the ECB following its establishment and the amounts called up at later dates. The ECB shall have the full right to hold and manage the foreign reserves that are transferred to it and to use them for the purposes set out in this Statute.
Article 49 (ex Article 52)
Following the irrevocable fixing of exchange rates in accordance with Article 140 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, the Governing Council shall take the necessary measures to ensure that banknotes denominated in currencies with irrevocably fixed exchange rates are exchanged by the national central banks at their respective par values.